Vestal, NY · Olive Oil & Balsamic Tasting Room

Taste Your Way to the Perfect Olive Oil

A gourmet boutique with a tasting room of flavored olive oils and aged balsamic vinegars. Sample dozens of flavors, find your favorites, and take them home.

Shop the Flavors Visit the Tasting Room

Taste before you buy · Friendly, knowledgeable staff · Local Vestal boutique

4.5/5 · 29 Google reviews
Dozensof Flavors to Taste
LocalVestal, New York
Bottles of flavored olive oil and balsamic vinegar in the Gallagher Olive Oil tasting room. The Tasting Room

Shop the Boutique

Olive Oils, Balsamics & Gifts

A taste of what's on our shelves. Swap in your real bestsellers, photos, and prices.

Bestseller Extra Virgin Olive Oils

Extra Virgin Olive Oils

From $15.95

Smooth, robust, and everything between — fresh extra virgin olive oils for cooking and finishing.

Shop Now
Most Flavors Balsamic Vinegars

Balsamic Vinegars

From $15.95

“All kinds of flavors” — aged and infused balsamics, from bright fruit to rich, syrupy classics.

Shop Now
Great Gift Gift Sets & Pairings

Gift Sets & Pairings

From $44.95

Curated olive oil & balsamic pairings, boxed and ready to give for any occasion.

Shop Now

What customers love about Gallagher Olive Oil

4.5 on Google “All kinds of flavors” “Pleasant & helpful staff” Olive Oil & Balsamic Gourmet Gift Sets

The Tasting Room

A Gourmet Boutique You Taste With

At Gallagher Olive Oil, you don't guess — you taste. Our Vestal tasting room invites you to sample a wide range of extra virgin and flavored olive oils alongside aged and infused balsamic vinegars, so every bottle you bring home is one you already love.

From bright, peppery olive oils to rich, syrupy balsamics in flavors for everything from salads to desserts, our staff will help you find the perfect pairing. It's the kind of personal, local experience you can't get from a supermarket shelf.

Shop the Flavors
A row of tasting fustis holding olive oils and balsamic vinegars on the tasting bar.

About Us

Family-Run & Flavor-Obsessed

Gallagher Olive Oil is a local gourmet boutique in Vestal, New York, built on a simple belief: great olive oil and balsamic vinegar should be tasted, not guessed at.

We hand-pick a wide range of extra virgin and flavored olive oils alongside aged and infused balsamics, and our staff is here to help you find the perfect pairing — personal, friendly, and rooted in the flavors we're proud to share.

Visit the Tasting Room

Why Gallagher Olive Oil

Why Locals Keep Coming Back

Taste Before You Buy

Sample any oil or balsamic in our tasting room and leave with bottles you already know you love.

Dozens of Flavors

A wide selection of extra virgin and flavored olive oils plus aged, infused balsamic vinegars for every dish.

Friendly Expert Staff

“Every staff member is very pleasant and helpful.” Real, knowledgeable guidance to find your perfect pairing.

Events & Special Offers

Dont Miss Out On Special Events & Offers

Sign up to get emails about upcoming tastings, new arrivals, and special offers from the Gallagher Olive Oil tasting room in Vestal, NY.

We'll only email about events and offers. Unsubscribe anytime.

From Our Customers

Rated 4.5★ on Google

4.5 / 5 average from 29 Google reviews

Luv this place — they have all kinds of flavors of balsamic vinaigrette.
c napGoogle review
Every staff member with whom you interact is very pleasant and helpful.
Tim HubbardGoogle review
A little pricey, but I have been very satisfied with my purchases there.
AnnmarieRozeGoogle review

Read all Google reviews

Free TastingSample before you buy
Local BoutiqueVestal, New York
4.5★ RatedOn 29 Google reviews
Perfect GiftsPairings & gift sets

Visit the Tasting Room

Find Us in Vestal, NY

Stop in to taste, ask questions, and pick out your favorites with help from our staff.

Get Directions Call Now

Questions, Answered

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I taste before I buy?
Yes — our tasting room lets you sample our olive oils and balsamic vinegars so you can find the flavors you love before you buy.
What do you sell?
We're a gourmet food boutique offering a wide range of extra virgin and flavored olive oils, aged and infused balsamic vinegars, and specialty gourmet foods.
Where are you located and what are your hours?
We're at 1708 Vestal Pkwy E, Vestal, NY 13850 — call us at (607) 748-2546. Add your full weekly hours; Google currently shows we close at 6 PM.
Do you offer gift baskets?
Yes — we offer ready-made and custom gift sets of olive oils and balsamic vinegars. Ask a staff member or call ahead.

Gallagher Olive Oil · Vestal, NY

Find Your New Favorite Flavor

Shop our olive oils and balsamics online, or join our list for new flavors, tastings, and offers.

Shop the Flavors

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe in one click. Your details stay private.