Shop Our Premium Olive Oil
Premium infused olive oils, crafted from the finest olives sourced around the world. Each oil is thoughtfully infused with bold, distinctive flavors to bring depth and character to every dish. Whether you're drizzling, dressing, finishing, or sautéing, these luxury oils elevate everyday cooking into something memorable. Explore the full range and find your new kitchen favorite.
Olive Oil
Bacon Infused Olive Oil
Featured
Bacon Olive Oil
$6.95
Our Bacon Infused Olive Oil is a versatile kitchen companion for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Use it to fry or scramble eggs, drizzle it over roasted brussels sprouts, or finish baked or mashed potatoes. Paired with Sherry Reserva, it makes a wonderful warm bacon dressing for spinach salad.
It also pairs beautifully with Bourbon Maple, Espresso, Chocolate di Torino, Peach, and many more.
Olive Oil
Basil Olive Oil
Featured
Basil Olive Oil
$6.95
This delicate Super Premium extra virgin olive oil is kissed by the bright and bold flavor of fresh basil oil extract. The vibrant and complex aroma and flavor of freshly chopped basil leaves are unequivocal. This bestselling olive oil beautifully enhances pasta, tomato-based soups, grilled vegetables, and soft cheeses. Use it as a base for a vibrant and flavorful pesto, drizzle it over homemade tomato soup and use it to sauté, grill or roast vegetables, especially eggplant.
Olive Oil
Blood Orange Olive Oil
Featured
Blood Orange Olive Oil
$6.95
Bright and zesty, this Super Premium EVOO is made with the fresh oil extract of Italian blood oranges. The sweet, slightly tart taste of blood oranges makes this olive oil even more attractive. Piquant but never pithy or bitter, it is clean, bright, citrusy, and almost exotic in aroma. Its versatile flavor profile and fruit forward aroma make this oil a staff and customer favorite. Drizzle it over oven roasted or grilled fish, combine it with your favorite vinegar to dress a salad, or bake into olive oil cakes and muffins. You will love it!
Olive Oil
Butter Olive Oil
Featured
Butter Olive Oil (savory)
$6.95
Reminiscent of the sweet flavor of freshly churned butter from the green hills of Normandy, this remarkably delicious butter infused olive oil is a wonderful vegan alternative. Its texture is smooth and silky, while its delicate savory flavor can please the palate of the most seasoned chef. Whether you use it to toss pasta, pop popcorn, drizzle over vegetables, or use it in baked goods, you will find this butter infused olive oil to be remarkably versatile.
Olive Oil
Butter Olive Oil
Featured
Butter Olive Oil (sweet)
$6.95
Utilizing vegetal extracts, sweet butter-infused olive oil offers all the health benefits of extra virgin olive oil and the delicious flavor of sweet butter without actually using butter. Its caramel top notes and rich, creamy center point make this olive oil the perfect substitute for melted butter in your favorite baking recipes. It is a versatile, all-purpose cooking olive oil that not only is very well suited for baked potatoes, eggs, steamed vegetables, pasta, and rice, but also is the “secret ingredient” to making the most delicious popcorn!
Olive Oil
Chipotle Olive Oil
Featured
Chipotle Olive Oil
$6.95
Natural chipotle pepper oil extracts are added to our Super Premium extra virgin olive oil to create a deep, rich and smoke-dried chipotle flavor explosion that is highlighted with a hint of smoked hickory. This well balanced infused EVOO is a customer favorite and perfect for grilled or smoked chicken and meat. Southwestern cuisine fans will be inspired by this authentic chipotle flavor and aroma. A 5 out of 10 on the heat index.
Olive Oil
Cilantro & Red Onion Olive Oil
Featured
Cilantro & Red Onion Olive Oil
$6.95
A nice balance of astringent and sweet, our cilantro & red onion infused olive oil has a very fresh depth of flavor. Its herbaceous piquant notes translate to a perfect olive oil for Latin, Asian and Middle Eastern dishes. We especially like using it in fish, chicken, flank or skirt steak marinades, but it is also exceptionally delicious drizzled over freshly grilled corn. Our go-to olive oil for tacos, guacamole, salsas, chili and rice.
Olive Oil
Cold Smoked Olive Oil
Featured
Cold Smoked Olive Oil
$6.95
Our Spanish Arbequina gets hit with a blast of hickory cold smoke to bring you this truly unique extra virgin olive oil. The aroma and taste of this oil impart wonderful creamy smokiness. Deliciously versatile, it is a fantastic complement to meats and vegetables. Drizzle over everything from chops to grilled vegetables, seafood, baked beans and even eggs! This is a fun olive oil to experiment with.
Olive Oil
Dill Olive Oil
Featured
Dill Olive Oil
$6.95
Wonderfully fragrant, bright, and delightful, this infused extra virgin olive oil tastes just like the fresh herb. It’s deep, almost anise-like flavor is pleasantly savory. While it is superb for salad dressings, finishing creamy soups, or to flavor your favorite Scandinavian-inspired dishes, we also love this Dill oil in fish, chicken, and lamb marinades. However, to really enjoy it’s flavor in its unadulterated state, be sure to drizzle it over poached salmon or gravlax!
Our Complete Catalouge
Olive Oils
Indulge in the art of fine olive oil at Gallagher Olive Oil, a specialty food boutique in Vestal, New York. Our curated collection of premium extra virgin olive oils brings together rich, golden flavors from around the world, each one chosen for its quality, freshness, and distinctive character.From smooth and buttery to bold and peppery, our olive oils are crafted to elevate every dish, whether you're finishing a crisp salad, roasting seasonal vegetables, or savoring it simply with warm artisan bread. Explore infused and flavored varieties alongside classic extra virgin selections, and discover the perfect oil for your table.What makes the experience truly special is our tasting room, where you're invited to sample and compare flavor profiles before you buy. It's a more personal, more luxurious way to find an olive oil you'll love.